• HOME
  • ABOUT US
  • SERVICES
  • PRODUCTS
  • RESOURCES
    • SCIENCE Corner
    • Teacher Resources
  • RESEARCH
  • ORDER
  • REGISTER
  • MSS i3
  Making Sense of SCIENCE

Incorrect Ideas

4/29/2014

 
Cailean Cooke
Have you ever been surprised to discover that a science idea you thought was true, was actually incorrect? If so, you aren’t alone. On the Making Sense of SCIENCE project, we call these ideas common-yet-incorrect ideas, or CYIIs for short. On the surface many CYIIs seem logical, like this one about plants’ food, which can make them hard to dislodge.

The text: fertilizer and sunlight are food for plants with a big X crossing it out
Misconceptions like the one in this CYII are often reinforced by our everyday experiences. Likely you’ve seen many plants flourishing in nutrient-rich, moist soil. From a young age you also learned that plants like to be showered with sunshine and all living organisms need food to thrive. More likely than not, you’ve also heard fertilizers advertised as “plant food.”  So it’s easy to incorrectly connect the dots and assume the nutrients and sunlight are food for plants. 
In truth, “plant food” is more complicated. While there are a few exceptions, most plants use the process of photosynthesis to generate their own food. That is, they use energy from sunlight to change carbon dioxide and water into glucose — their food. In fact, most of the matter plants use for photosynthesis does not come from water or nutrient-rich soil. It comes from carbon dioxide in the air! 
Revelations like this are a natural part of learning science for teachers and students alike. So, why all the fuss about the wrong ideas?
Perhaps the biggest reason to examine commonly held, incorrect ideas (and the logic behind them) is that they give us insight into students’ science ideas and how they make sense of the world around them. Talking about CYIIs helps teachers develop strategies that can move students toward more complete, accurate, and precise understandings.
Making Sense of SCIENCE materials illustrate common, incorrect ideas alongside the correct idea. Research has shown that contrasting an incorrect idea with a correct one helps us understand the underlying concept more fully (Durkin, Rittle-Johnson, 2009).  In fact, one strategy for helping students dislodge their own incorrect ideas is to show them contrasting CYII examples like these.
IDEAS about Plants Food. Incorrect: Fertilizer and sunlight are food for plants. Correct: Fertilizer is an input of matter and sunlight is an input of energy that help plants make their own food (glucose).
We’d love to hear stories of CYIIs you or your students have had. What incorrect science ideas have you heard? What about the idea seemed logical? How might you help someone with this CYII reach a more complete, accurate, and precise understanding?

Comments are closed.
    MSS Science Corner

    Archives

    December 2019
    August 2019
    May 2019
    March 2019
    November 2018
    August 2018
    April 2018
    January 2018
    November 2017
    February 2017
    October 2016
    June 2016
    March 2016
    December 2015
    August 2015
    June 2015
    April 2015
    February 2015
    October 2014
    September 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    January 2014

    Categories

    All
    CYIIs
    Energy
    Formative Assessment
    Languages Of Science
    Life Science
    Literacy
    Matter
    Misconceptions
    Models & Modeling
    Phenomena-Based Instruction
    Research
    Scientific Explanations
    Student Ideas
    Student Work

    RSS Feed

Facebook
Twitter
YouTube
Subscribe to e-MeSSage for the latest news on Making Sense of SCIENCE events, resources, and more.
For more information about our project, services, materials, and event registration, contact Patrick Moyle at ​mssevents@wested.org or 510.302.4219.

HOME  •  SERVICES  •  PRODUCTS  •  RESOURCES  •  ABOUT US  •  ORDER  •  REGISTER

Other links: MSS Errata • 
e-MeSSage registration • End User Lisence Agreement (2019)

Making Sense of SCIENCE is a project of WestEd, a research, development, and service agency promoting excellence, achieving equity, and improving learning for children, youth, and adults. Since its inception in 1966, WestEd has been a leader in moving research into practice.

© 2017 WestEd. All rights reserved.  Privacy Policy | Disclaimer
WestEd logo